SUPERLOK® NORTH AMERICA · VALVE KNOWLEDGE
How to Size a Relief Valve for Instrument Service
The order of work: protected system, overpressure scenario, required relieving rate, then the orifice, and what the catalog can and cannot supply.
To size a relief valve you need a scenario before you need a catalog, and most sizing mistakes are scenario mistakes. This post walks through the logic for instrument service and marks where the numbers come from. Superlok® relief valves are listed with pressure ranges and an orifice, but their pages state no relieving capacity, and we make no capacity claim here. According to Crowl and Tipler, writing in Chemical Engineering Progress, the professional magazine of AIChE and not a manufacturer, the work starts by defining the protected system and the overpressure scenarios, and only then moves to the design basis and the relief area. The earlier notes on relief valve set pressure and relief valve blowdown cover the other two numbers you will need.
How to Size a Relief Valve: Work in This Order
Crowl and Tipler set out a flowchart: define the protected system, locate the devices, choose the type, define the overpressure scenarios, acquire the sizing data, decide whether flow is single-phase or two-phase, set the design basis, then design the relief system. For an instrument circuit the protected system is usually short: a regulator outlet, a sample loop, a transmitter impulse line, or a section of tubing between two isolation valves.
Ask first whether a valve is needed at all. Chip Eskridge, in Chemical Processing on 10 February 2006, says that if the weakest component can withstand the highest pressure that can develop, a relief device is not required. Where it cannot, the device has to be sized for the scenario that produces that pressure, and the pressure ratings page is where the tube and fitting limits sit.
Choose the Relieving Scenario
Crowl and Tipler list the usual causes: failure of a control valve, an uncontrolled reaction, thermal expansion of a liquid, and external fire. Their own mixing-vessel example adds a nitrogen regulator failure and a pump running against a closed outlet, and they note that credible scenarios typically involve a single failure. On instrument lines two of these dominate. One is a pressure regulator that fails open and sends supply pressure into a section rated lower. The other is liquid trapped between closed valves, which the note on thermal relief valves covers.
Write the scenario down with its numbers: source pressure, what fails, fluid, temperature, and the lowest rating downstream. Each scenario can give a different required rate, and the valve must handle the governing one.
Find the Required Relieving Rate
The rate is a mass or volume flow that must leave the system to hold pressure at the allowed limit. Crowl and Tipler say the design basis includes the mass discharge rate through the device. How you find it depends on the scenario.
For a failed pressure-control device, Spirax Sarco, a steam-equipment manufacturer whose pages are manufacturer publications, describes the fault flow as depending on the upstream fault pressure, the relieving pressure of the valve being sized, and the full-open flow coefficient of the upstream control valve. It writes about steam and upstream control valves, but the logic carries to a regulator on gas or liquid: ask how much the failed regulator can pass, not how much the process normally uses. Spirax Sarco adds that where several flow paths exist, the valve may be sized on the largest single fault or on combined flows, and that the plant’s insurer has the final say.
For heat input, Eskridge gives one formula, for high-heat-flux cases such as exchangers and steam-traced or jacketed lines, as an energy balance on the cold side:
W = Q / ΔHv, where W is the relieving rate in lb/hr, Q is the hot-side heat input in Btu/hr, and ΔHv is the heat of vaporization of the cold fluid at the set pressure.
The same article says low-heat-flux cases such as solar heating are much harder to calculate accurately, and warns that flashing two-phase flow can make single-phase sizing give erroneous results. The area equations in Crowl and Tipler and the capacity equations in the Spirax Sarco pages are not reproduced here: we could not read them reliably as text, and we will not quote them from memory.
From Required Rate to Orifice
The last step turns the rate into a relief area. Crowl and Tipler describe the goal as determining the required area, using a discharge coefficient that for code-certified devices can be obtained from the ASME National Board, and they state that ASME-certified valves must reach full rated capacity at 10 percent or less overpressure. Spirax Sarco says to use the manufacturer’s or an independently certified coefficient, to derate it by multiplying by 0.9, and never to calculate capacity at a lower overpressure than the one at which the coefficient was established.
That is where a catalog has to cooperate, and where ours stops. The SRVL and SRVH listings give a 4.8 mm orifice, cracking pressure ranges of 10 to 250 psig and 225 to 6000 psig, and maximum operating pressures of 300 and 6000 psig. They give no coefficient, no certified capacity and no flow curve. A sizing calculation cannot be closed on those pages alone. Send the scenario and we will tell you what is listed; do not assume a figure.
| Input | Comes from | On the Superlok® pages? |
|---|---|---|
| Scenario | Your process design | No |
| Required rate | Scenario calculation | No |
| Set pressure | Weakest component and operating pressure | Cracking ranges listed |
| Orifice | Valve data | 4.8 mm listed |
| Discharge coefficient and capacity | Manufacturer or certified data | Not stated |
Source basis: Crowl and Tipler, Eskridge, Spirax Sarco and the Superlok® listings named below.
Oversizing and the Code Line
Bigger is not safer. Crowl and Tipler say oversized relief devices may become unstable in operation, which is the chatter problem described in the blowdown note. Size to the governing scenario, then check closing behaviour. A listing in 316 stainless steel, a corrosion-resistant alloy, is stated on specific variants only; elsewhere grade is confirmed per order.
The line is simple: where a design requires an ASME code-stamped safety valve, an instrumentation relief valve is not a substitute, and this post is not a basis for choosing one. For the code vocabulary see relief valve vs safety valve, and for the listings themselves see the SRVL and SRVH pages.
Questions
What is the first step in sizing?
Define the protected system and the overpressure scenario. The valve is sized to what the scenario can deliver, not to the process’s normal flow.
Does the orifice size set the relieving capacity?
Not alone. Capacity also depends on pressure, fluid and the discharge coefficient. The Superlok® pages list a 4.8 mm orifice and no capacity.
Can I use the 4.8 mm orifice to calculate flow myself?
Not from these pages. The sources call for a manufacturer or certified coefficient, which the listings do not state.
Is a bigger valve safer?
No. Crowl and Tipler note that oversized devices may become unstable in operation.
Have a scenario to check?
Send the source pressure, the fluid and the lowest rating downstream.
SUPERLOK® NORTH AMERICA
Built for instrument circuits, to the finest interior surface finish of any tube and pipe fitting on the market.
Sources
- Daniel A. Crowl and Scott A. Tipler, “Sizing Pressure-Relief Devices,” Chemical Engineering Progress, October 2013 (AIChE). Supports the sizing flowchart, the scenario list, the design basis, the certified-valve overpressure statement and the oversizing remark. Its area equations were not legible as text and are not reproduced. aiche.org
- Chip Eskridge, “Assessing Pressure Relief Needs,” Chemical Processing, 10 February 2006 (trade press). Supports the no-device-needed test, the energy balance W = Q / ΔHv for high heat flux, and the low-heat-flux and two-phase cautions. chemicalprocessing.com
- Spirax Sarco (steam-equipment manufacturer; manufacturer publication), “Safety Valve Sizing,” Learn About Steam. Supports the fault flow description, the largest-fault versus combined-flow choice, and the coefficient handling. Its equations are images and are not reproduced. spiraxsarco.com
- Superlok® North America, SRVL and SRVH product listings (manufacturer of record). Supports the orifice, cracking and maximum operating pressure figures and the absence of any capacity or coefficient. SRVL and SRVH
Technical note: The sources establish the order of work, the scenario types, one stated energy-balance formula and the rule on discharge coefficients. They do not give an instrument-scale sizing method, a general area equation we could quote, or any capacity for the SRVL or SRVH series. The Spirax Sarco material is written for steam and is applied to regulators here as reasoning, not as a source claim. No capacity is claimed for any Superlok® part. Grade and rating confirmed per order.
Trademark disclaimer: Superlok® is a registered trademark. AIChE, Chemical Processing, Spirax Sarco, ASME and the National Board are named only to identify sources and standards and belong to their owners. Cross-references are made by form, fit, and function only.






